Report: Former Cowboys assistant to return to Dallas as Schottenheimer’s coordinator angeltorres Dallas’s hiring of Brian Schottenheimer as their next head coach was quickly followed by a report of who will be in charge of the defense. It appears Dallas will also bring back former assistant coach Matt Eberflus as the team’s defensive coordinator. The former linebackers coach spent seven seasons in Dallas, from 2011 through 2017. The Cowboys front office reportedly wanted Eberflus to take over as defensive coordinator after the 2017 season for an aging Rod Marinelli but he refused to undercut his mentor. Instead, the rising defensive coach took the Indianapolis defensive coordinator job under then-head coach Josh McDaniels. In the 2020 and 2021 seasons, Eberflus helped the Colts defense become the only team in the league to have his squad rank in the top ten in scoring, run defense, and takeaways. In four seasons, his turnovers and run defense in Indy never fell out of the league’s top 10 rankings. Eberflus spent the last three seasons as Chicago’s head coach, accumulating a 14-32 record in his Bears tenure. Eberflus set Chicago’s franchise record with a 14-game losing streak and was fired midway through the 2024 season after an embarrassing clock management blunder on Thanksgiving against the Lions. He now becomes the third defensive coordinator in the past three seasons for Dallas and has the task of creating mismatches for defensive end Micah Parsons, among others. Dallas signed Mike Zimmer to a one-year contract to be the team’s defensive coordinator before the 2024 season and appears to be a one-and-done situation. Terms of the Eberflus deal have not been disclosed.
4 reasons why Matt Eberflus would be a good hire for the Cowboys
Photo by Amy Lemus/NurPhoto via Getty Images There are plenty of reasons to be excited about a potential addition of Matt Eberflus. It wasn’t that long ago when the Dallas Cowboys were lacking coaches. Now, just a few days later, they have named Brian Schottenheimer as their new head coach and Matt Eberflus is gaining a lot of buzz as their potential new defensive coordinator. On Saturday, our own David Howman discussed why the Schottenheimer decision makes sense for the Cowboys. Today, we’ll look at what they would be getting in reuniting with an old friend. Getting the timing right Fans might remember Eberflus from his first stint with the Cowboys starting back in 2011 when he came over from Cleveland with then-defensive coordinator Rob Ryan. While Ryan’s time in Dallas was short-lived, Eberflus was able to hang around. When the team moved on from Ryan and replaced him with Monte Kiffin and then Rod Marinelli, Eberflus became the team’s linebacker coach. Eberflus spent seven years in Dallas and by 2018, his ability as a coach was being recognized. The Cowboys wanted to promote him to defensive coordinator, but they still had Marinelli so they tried to get sly and just re-title Marinelli as the assistant head coach, opening up the DC position for Eberflus. Not wanting to create tension, Eberflus left Dallas and joined the Indianapolis Colts as their new defensive coordinator. Eberflus’ success continued in Indy and he was hired by the Chicago Bears to be their new head coach in 2022. The gig in Chicago didn’t work out after three losing seasons (almost three, he was fired after Week 13), so now he’s going back to what he does best, and this time around, the Cowboys do have an opening at defensive coordinator. Combined with the offensive-minded Schottenheimer, Eberflus feels like the perfect fit. The linebacker whisperer The former linebackers coach has a strong track record for getting the most out of his linebackers wherever he goes. Starting in Dallas, he was gifted the talented Sean Lee who played at an All-Pro level whenever he was healthy. But Eberflus did a lot with other guys too. Bruce Carter put together strong performances in Dallas, including a five-interception season in 2014. Anthony Hitchens also played beyond expectations with four solid years. Both he and Carter left for a nice payday after their rookie contracts expired with the Cowboys. Eberflus also helped rejuvenate Rolando McClain’s career during his short return to the league. He did the same thing in Indianapolis. Shaq Leonard had four All-Pro seasons with the Colts and then quickly faded. It just so happens that those four years were the same four years Eberflus was with the team. Joining the Cowboys staff should help get the most out of the linebackers, just as former defensive line coach Dan Quinn helped their pass rush and former defensive backs coach Mike Zimmer worked miracles with their injury-riddled secondary. Eberflus will inherit the rising talent of Marist Liufau and hopefully the eventual return of DeMarvion Overshown. Take it away When Quinn was here, the Cowboys’ defense was one of the best units in the league at taking the ball away. They finished No. 1 in the league in 2021 and 2022 with a combined total of 67 forced turnovers. It was a huge reason the Cowboys had one of the stronger defenses in the league. The Cowboys have slipped a little these past two years as they’ve ranked 12th in takeaways in each of the last two years, but the Eberflus influence should help sharpen some of that thievery. As a defensive coordinator, his Colts’ units finished in the top 10 in takeaways all four seasons with the team. They finished inside the top 10 in interceptions all four years and inside the top 10 in fumble recoveries in three of his four seasons with the team. When it comes to taking the ball away, his squads are pretty good at it. Stingy with the points Forcing turnovers is great, but keeping opposing offensives out of the end zone is what really matters. During his time with the Colts, his defenses finished in the top 10 in points allowed three times. This was a breath of fresh air for a Colts defense that had finished outside the top 20 in points allowed in each of the previous three seasons, including the third-worst the season right before Eberflus showed up. Eberflus has done a good job shutting teams down. The Cowboys know this firsthand. Only once has Dallas been shut out in a game over the last 20 years and it just so happens to be the time they faced Eberflus’ Colts where they lost 23-0 back in 2019.
Cowboys news: Brian Schottenheimer has a past, but his future success is an unknown
Schottenheimer hire essentially Cowboys’ version of Schrodinger’s Cat – Reid Hanson, Cowboys Wire Despite the frustration with the hiring of Brian Schottenheimer, it’s still unknown what could come from his tenure as head coach. The hope that typically follows a new coaching hire was absent from this transaction. Schottenheimer had a rather spotty record as an offensive coordinator and despite being a lifelong coach, he’d never elevated to the position of head coach before. But it’s that level of unknown that inspires just the smallest nugget of optimism. The idea Schottenheimer has never had full control of the team before offers up a “superposition” of sorts. Given all the unknown, Schottenheimer is both a success and failure at the moment. He’s a mystery much like Schrodinger’s Cat in the famous thought experiment of an observer’s paradox. In a nutshell, Schrodinger’s Cat is a hypothetical situation in which a cat is locked in a box while being exposed to possibly deadly radiation. A person can assume the cat is dead given the circumstances, but until someone opens the box to confirm the status of the cat, the cat is both alive and dead. Schottenheimer’s inexperience as a head coach and years of working in the background make him an unknown, much like that cat. There’s plenty of reason to think he’ll be underwhelming but until someone actually observes him coach in 2025, he’s also a potential success. Among many other things in this well-researched article, Epstein explains what a colleague from his play-calling days expects Schotty’s scheme to look like. A league executive who worked with Schottenheimer at one of his offensive coordinator stops described the blended philosophies that could guide the system he would build for the Cowboys. In Seattle, he adjusted his system to the terminology then-Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson already knew to improve consistency for Wilson, the executive told Yahoo Sports. That process would be even smoother should Schottenheimer carry over language for Prescott as he’s already operated in the same language. With the Jets, Schottenheimer was gap-scheme oriented, the executive said, while later working with more wide-zone and play-action concepts. Tempo and screen game wrinkles trace his Seattle play-calling, Schottenheimer unafraid then to implement pass concepts even on early downs. The Cowboys’ hire may be neither creative nor inspiring in league circles. That doesn’t mean it can’t work. “I would not be surprised at all to see Schotty have success as a head coach,” the executive and former Schottenheimer colleague said. “He’s really organized. He’s a direct communicator. He’s got some fire. He’s got some edge. “He did some really good things [here], things that I probably didn’t [appreciate then] full scale.” How Jerry, Stephen Jones can assure Cowboys fans amid divisive Brian Schottenheimer hiring – David Moore, DMN Cowboys cannot afford to sit on their hands again in free agency. Vitriol of the move — if that’s your response — is likely reserved for Jerry and Stephen Jones. They are the ones on trial with fans here, much more so than Schottenheimer. Both men are aware of their current standing in popularity polls. Father and son are under no delusions that this move will energize or even appease an increasingly frustrated fan base. That shifts the focus to March 12. That’s the next chance the Jones family has to slowly begin to change hardened hearts and minds. Will Jones squared show they have learned the painful lessons of a 7-10 season? Will they alter their approach to free agency for the first time in more than a decade? “Maybe we could have done a better job of betting on the come with some of the young guys,‘’ Stephen Jones said in November. “Maybe we could have gone a little more into the future to help the current team. Maybe we should have pushed a little more (money) out. “We’ve got to look at that.‘’ Hiring Schottenheimer was only the first step. There are more for Jerry and Stephen Jones to take before fans can become excited about the 2025 season. Jerry Jones’ worst nightmare: Approach to Cowboys’ hire could invoke fan apathy – Saad Youssuf, The Athletic. At some point, your customers will notice that you aren’t investing in your business and are treating them as cash cows. Fans buy jerseys. They show up for training camp in Oxnard, Calif., albeit in decreasing numbers lately. Road games often feel like home games because Dallas fans come in droves. Many would call the Cowboys’ hiring of Brian Schottenheimer on Friday night as the next head coach a decision founded in comfort and safety. While that’s true from a football operations standpoint, it’s also perhaps the riskiest decision Jones could have made. That risk isn’t tied to wins and losses, but something Jones cares about even more. Apathy. Sports entertainment shows will discuss the Schottenheimer hiring for the next few weeks. Fans will offer their remarks about it for a little while, too. But after the initial wave — which coincides with a conference championship weekend featuring two division rivals and then the Super Bowl — passes, how does Jones convince Dallas fans to care? What cards does he have left to play? The bottom line has been unaffected so far, but the risk for Jones’ worst nightmare — fan apathy — has never been higher than it is right now. Winners and losers of Cowboys’ Brian Schottenheimer hire – Nate Davis, USA Today Three names from Davis’ list of winners and losers, Winners: Dak Prescott Continuity was important to the Dallas quarterback, who’s set to enter his 10th season after a blown hamstring cut his ninth short. But Prescott’s best year in the NFL occurred in 2023, when he led the league with 36 touchdown passes and was the runner-up for MVP. Former coach Mike McCarthy was calling the plays then, but Schottenheimer had a front-row seat to what worked so well. The goal moving forward will clearly be to get the QB back at that
NFC East news: Which Cowboys rival advances to the Super Bowl?
Peter Casey-Imagn Images Which NFC East team do you hope wins on Sunday? Eagles injury update: Key Eagles return to practice ahead of NFC Championship Game – Dave Zangaro, NBC Sports Philadelphia Philly is getting healthy just in time for the conference championship game. Starting center Cam Jurgens (back) and tight end Dallas Goedert (ankle) returned to practice on Friday ahead of the Eagles’ NFC Championship Game against the Commanders on Sunday. Both Jurgens and Goedert were listed as non-participants to start the week and neither practiced on Thursday. So it was a good sign for the Eagles to have them both back on the field Friday, participating in the final practice of the week. In fact, every player on the Eagles’ 53-man roster was on the field as the Eagles practiced in their indoor bubble at the NovaCare Complex. Practice was initially scheduled to be held at the Linc but the Eagles moved it inside instead. During these playoffs, Goedert has been the Eagles’ leading receiver with 8 catches for 103 yards. He also gives them a lot as a blocker in their run game. The Eagles’ backup tight ends on the roster are Grant Calcaterra and E.J. Jenkins. Jalen Hurts (knee) was back on the field Friday after being upgraded to a full participant on Thursday. He’s going to play in the NFC Championship Game, it’s just a matter of how mobile he will be. “I think he’s had a good week of practice,” head coach Nick Sirianni said, “and I think he’s done some really good things all week. We’ll see.” The other notable injury coming out of Sunday’s game was to rookie cornerback Quinyon Mitchell (shoulder). But the rookie was also upgraded to a full participant on Thursday and has already said he’s playing. What is the Biggest Concern For the Washington Commanders Against the Eagles? – Caleb Skinner, Sports Illustrated A devastating injury along their offensive line could be troublesome for Jayden Daniels. It is almost time for the Washington Commanders to play in a game they haven’t been to in over 30 years when they face off against the Philadelphia Eagles for a third time this season in the NFC Championship game. The Commanders aren’t favored to come out victorious but they have shown before that they shouldn’t be doubted. As mentioned, this team goes as the offense goes, and that will be much needed on Sunday when they head to Philly. Jayden Daniels and his cast have been phenomenal this season and will again look to put points on the scoreboard. Unfortunately for Daniels and the offense, they will have to continue battling without their star offensive lineman Sam Cosmi who suffered a torn ACL ending his season. With the game just on the horizon, CBS Sports’ Cody Benjamin wondered if Jayden Daniels’ play could help offset the absence left by Cosmi. “Lost in the magic of their divisional-round upset of the Detroit Lions was a season-ending injury to Cosmi, who’d quietly graded out as one of this year’s top 25 interior pass blockers, per PFF,” Benjamin wrote. “Daniels has an effortless ability to extend plays or move the chains with his legs, but now up against a stingy Eagles front that includes the ferocious Jalen Carter, he might need to be especially quick with his decisions.” Eli Manning willing to help Giants evaluate quarterbacks – Dan Benton, USA Today The Super Bowl-winning quarterback wants to help any way he can. The New York Giants enter the offseason with a singular goal in mind: Find the next franchise quarterback. That player could be signed as a free agent, acquired via trade, or selected in the 2025 NFL draft. There could even be multiple quarterbacks added in an effort to develop one while another serves as a bridge. However the Giants plan to approach it, retired legend Eli Manning is offering his help in evaluating the many options. “I like watching film,” Manning said, via the New York Post. “If that’s something I’m wanted for, needed for, be happy to look at film and get involved in that part of it.” Although Manning still works for the Giants in a business operations and fan engagement role, he is not currently involved in any sort of scouting. However, he has occasionally been asked for his input over the years. “Yes, I mean a little bit, just over the years, just guys I’ve been around, whether it’s Jaxson Dart of Ole Miss or quarterbacks over the years who have been to the Manning Passing Academy,” he said. “Just what kind of person they are, kind of more off-the-field stuff than maybe on the field.” Because of the Manning Passing Academy, Eli does have significant firsthand knowledge of most quarterback prospects. At some point or another, many cycle through the academy at least once with several making a multitude of appearances. That also provides Manning the opportunity to converse with the young quarterbacks who are headed to the NFL. And should the Giants hone in on anyone specific, Manning could get into their ear and help them understand the pressure that comes along with playing in New York. “It’s not an easy situation,” he said. “A lot of pressure, a lot of expectations and being in New York, really being around the NFL, they expect immediate results, which is not easy to do, in any market playing the quarterback position. Who do you got in the NFC Conference Championship game, the Eagles or the Commanders? Hit the comments and let us know your take.
The real reason why Jerry Jones hired Brian Schottenheimer instead of a big-name coach
The real reason why Jerry Jones hired Brian Schottenheimer instead of a big-name coach K.D. Drummond I started the conversation three or four years ago, returning each year since, in explaining why the Cowboys don’t sign external free agents. They conduct football operations like a Fortune 500 business that is too big to fail financially, but still doing things woefully incorrectly. This philosophy appears to have leaked into the process that led to Brian Schottenheimer being hired as the latest head coach. Follow the logic. Big player contracts are seen as rewards for prior performance to the company. Players earn big deals as thank yous for outperforming their previous contracts, kind of like 9-to-5 workers getting promotions. Despite his background as an oil guy, Jones has soured on speculation in his later years. Signing external free agents is all about what could be. Sure, a player could have proven his value for a different team, but there’s no guarantee he’ll be the same guy in a new organizational setting, under different coaching. Signing a guy to a huge amount of guaranteed salary when they’ve never done it in the fishbowl that is Dallas is a gamble the Jones family is no longer willing to take. This is why the club no longer plays the market in the first few waves of free agency. As time goes on, Jones has been less inclined to tread in those waters. That philosophy has now seeped into his coaching decisions and was on full display with everything that happened since Mike McCarthy’s contract expired at the end of the 2024 regular season. Jones did not envision a world where McCarthy wasn’t returning as the head coach, reportedly. He wasn’t dutifully prepared for a coaching search, assuming that after backing McCarthy into a corner as a lame-duck for 2024, the bad season on his resume would limit his external opportunities and convince him to return under Jones’ parameters. Those parameters allegedly included forcing a Jones “family member” (Jason Witten) onto McCarthy’s staff, and a shorter than normal contract length. The Jones ‘family’ photo, circa 2017. [image or embed] — KD Drummond (@kddrummondnfl.bsky.social) January 25, 2025 at 2:11 PM This was something Jones had done to Wade Phillips over a decade ago. Jones hired his guy, Jason Garrett, before Phillips was brought on board, letting the journeyman coach know his successor was already decided before working his first day on the job. Accusations exist regarding Garrett potentially purposefully contributing to the unraveling of the 2010 season. Jones also didn’t care how blocking McCarthy from interviewing with the Chicago Bears would come across to the outside world. When McCarthy balked at the offer, Jones was left scrambling for a solution. That included a quick conversation with Deion Sanders, a Jones favorite from the 1990 heydays who has shined in the CFB coaching circuit. Sanders was never brought in for an official interview, despite there being a compelling case, but word of their conversation “about the head coach position” was quickly run through the media’s tentacles in what seems to be an effort in distraction. It feels as if it was used as a cover while the brass formed an ad hoc process, while also attempting to give Sanders leverage in his discussions with his currently employer. In the end there were only four men interviewed for the head coach opening after McCarthy walked. The two true candidates were Schottenheimer and Kellen Moore, Schottenheimer’s predecessor as offensive coordinator. Moore is currently employed by the Philadelphia Eagles. He did a virtual interview last Friday, but the Eagles advancing to the NFCCG kept him from a follow up. The Jones family spent the week convincing themselves of Schottenheimer’s worthiness. The two other coaches Jones interviewed felt out of place. Both were ex-head coaches with horrible records who just so happened to be minorities, thus satisfying the NFL’s Rooney Rule (which is a whole separation serious conversation that needs to be had). Rober Saleh, 20-36, was fired midseason from the New York Jets and returned to San Francisco earlier Friday to be their defensive coordinator. That likely doesn’t happen if he feels he’s a serious candidate to be the Cowboys head coach. The other was Leslie Frazier, 21-32-1, currently an assistant head coach in Seattle currently. Were they seriously under consideration? A team with the prestige of the Dallas Cowboys only interviews two candidates who lacked prior ties to the organization and they both had miserable records? Jones never made a real effort to escape his comfort zone. Transitioning to Schottenheimer was literally the next-best thing to his original plan of keeping McCarthy on the cheap, furthering the idea that the coach’s exodus caught him off guard. The expected hiring of Matt Eberflus as defensive coordinator supports the idea of Jones’ proclivity to favor those who have worked for him before, rather than outsiders. While it’s being walked back that he’s a sure thing to take over the DC job, most know what it is. There’s a lot of scuttlebutt the team believes they satisfied the Rooney Rule for coordinators by claiming that Saleh and Frazier were considerations for both HC and DC, as they classified Schottenheimer’s initial interview as being for both HC and OC. If one walked away from this as them looking to shirk the rules, it’d be tough to argue them down. All in all though, things seem fairly obvious from the outside looking in. The Jones don’t trust their ability to look outside the organization for help. When it comes to players, there’s nothing that will convince them the risk is worth the reward. When it comes to head coaches, they will trust former champions, but even they could have conditions attached. It’s all a stressful existence for fans who have tied their sports happiness (and sometimes overall joy) to a franchise that has shrunked into it’s turtle shell. Follow all of your favorite Texas teams at Cowboys Wire, Longhorns Wire, Texans Wire, Rockets Wire and
The Cowboys need to get back to their old ways of drafting in 2025
Photo by Keith Birmingham/MediaNews Group/Pasadena Star-News via Getty Images The Cowboys need to get back to hitting home runs in the draft. The word “frustrating” has been used now more than ever to describe the Dallas Cowboys. Whether it has been through the Cowboys coaching search trying to replace Mike McCarthy, their lack of aggressiveness in free agency and the trade market, the way they have handled recent contract negotiations, or their performances in the playoffs, Cowboys fans are becoming quite familiar with being frustrated. One of the reasons they were as bad as they were in 2024 and their inability to get over the hump in the playoffs is because they simply have not drafted well over the last three-to-four years. NFC East rival and Super Bowl-contender, the Philadelphia Eagles, are coming off a year in which they added multiple Rookie of the Year candidates in Cooper DeJean and Quinyon Mitchell. In 2023, they added Jalen Carter and Nolan Smith. In 2022, they added Jordan Davis, Cam Jurgens, and Nakobe Dean to the fold and all those additions are key reasons they are competing for the NFC Championship this weekend. In their first year under new ownership, the Washington Commanders built a playoff contending team quickly adding Jayden Daniels, Jer’Zhan Newton, Mike Sainristil, and Brandon Coleman, all key pieces to the Commanders and their ability to reach the NFC Championship game. Photo by Sam Hodde/Getty Images For the Cowboys, they have struggled to add true-difference makers through the draft in recent years. Out of the 2024 draft, Cooper Beebe is the only player that played at an acceptable level. In 2023, DeMarvion Overshown is the only player drafted who has showed signs of being a true difference-maker, but after yet another devastating knee injury, the Cowboys would be wise to plan to be without Overshown for the foreseeable future. In 2022, Dallas did hit home runs with Tyler Smith and DaRon Bland, and Jake Ferguson has potential, but the rest of their 2022 draft class, who will be heading into the last year of their rookie deal in 2025, have left a lot to be desired. That more than anything is the key difference between the Eagles and the Commanders who have absolutely crushed their recent drafts, all while adding difference-makers in free agency over the last few offseasons. By now, Cowboy fans should not expect the team to make splashes in free agency, but with their inability to add multiple difference-makers in the last few drafts, it leaves them behind the eight ball in terms of roster building with the rest of their NFC rivals. Looking at it a bit deeper, the Los Angeles Rams, a team Stephen Jones has criticized on their team building strategy, has been a much better drafting team over the three-to-four year stretch we are talking about. The Rams have added Jared Verse, Braden Fiske, Kamren Kinchens, Beaux Limmer, Steve Avilla, Byron Young, Kobie Turner, Puka Nacua, Kyren Williams, and Cobie Durant, over the last three drafts, to continue to build a competitive roster after going “all-in” for their Super Bowl victory in 2021-2022. The Detroit Lions, a Super Bowl favorite over the last two years, have built their roster heavily through the draft, adding Terrion Arnold, Jahmyr Gibbs, Jack Campbell, Sam LaPorta, Brian Branch, Aidan Hutchinson, Jameson Williams, and Kerby Joseph through the last three drafts. The Cowboys playoff hopes live and die with how they do in the NFL Draft, and over the last three years they have added just four difference-makers, while their NFC rivals having much better luck building their team through the draft, while also using other resources to add talent. With uncertainty surrounding who will coach the team in 2025 and beyond, one thing is for certain, and that is for this team to get back to its winning ways they need to crush the 2025 NFL Draft. It has been quite a while since they have done so, but it is likely now-or-never for this team’s chances of making a playoff push.
Schottenheimer hire essentially Cowboys’ version of Schrodinger’s Cat
Schottenheimer hire essentially Cowboys’ version of Schrodinger’s Cat reidhanson When the Dallas Cowboys announced in their Friday night news dump that their next head coach would be former offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer, they probably knew what was coming. The hire most Cowboys fans feared for days had become a reality and the national media and NFL fans coast to coast were having a heyday with it. The hope that typically follows a new coaching hire was absent from this transaction. Schottenheimer had a rather spotty record as an offensive coordinator and despite being a lifelong coach, he’d never elevated to the position of head coach before. But it’s that level of unknown that inspires just the smallest nugget of optimism. The idea Schottenheimer has never had full control of the team before offers up a “superposition” of sorts. Given all the unknown, Schottenheimer is both a success and failure at the moment. He’s a mystery much like Schrodinger’s Cat in the famous thought experiment of an observer’s paradox. In a nutshell, Schrodinger’s Cat is a hypothetical situation in which a cat is locked in a box while being exposed to possibly deadly radiation. A person can assume the cat is dead given the circumstances, but until someone opens the box to confirm the status of the cat, the cat is both alive and dead. Schottenheimer’s inexperience as a head coach and years of working in the background make him an unknown, much like that cat. There’s plenty of reason to think he’ll be underwhelming but until someone actually observes him coach in 2025, he’s also a potential success. That’s the benefit of an unknown. The main criticisms of Schottenheimer stem from his brand of offense. The run-run-pass approach isn’t an appropriate formula this day and age, not even with the sport’s current running game resurgence. The coaching tree in which Schottenheimer has grown from is uninspiring, to say the least, and there has been little indication he’s going to stray from what he’s shown in the past. Even still, he worked in the background behind Mike McCarthy throughout his time with the Cowboys so it’s unclear what an off-leash Schottenheimer really looks like. There’s little reason to think this will be a great success but at the same time there’s no way to know for sure until the new season starts. The heavily scrutinized Schottenheimer hire is the Cowboys’ version of Schrodinger’s Cat and it will be roughly seven months before anyone gets to peek inside the box to confirm which way this situation falls. Related articles [affiliatewidget_smgtolocal] Read all the best Cowboys coverage at the Austin American-Statesman and Cowboys Wire.
A closer look at why an all-NFC East championship game is the peak of Cowboys embarrassing fallout
Photo by Nic Antaya/Getty Images It may be hard to believe, but there are still NFL teams playing football this weekend. Four of them to be exact, meaning, of course, that Sunday’s games will determine who plays in Super Bowl LIX in New Orleans. A division rival of the Dallas Cowboys is guaranteed to be there as the Philadelphia Eagles host the Washington Commanders in the NFC Championship Game. For the Eagles, it will be their third appearance in this game over the last eight seasons. Representing a division well-known for not having any repeat winners for more than the last two decades, the Eagles have found some consistency in a place it matters much more – the postseason. The Commanders appearance in Sunday’s early game is their first since 1991, which officially made the Cowboys drought of not appearing a win away from the Super Bowl since 1996 the longest in the conference. When the Eagles and Commanders square off for the third time this season, looking to determine a series winner after both teams defended home field in the regular season, it will be a matchup of former Cowboys coaches in Eagles OC Kellen Moore and Commanders HC Dan Quinn as well. While Dallas’ circus of a coaching search ended with internal candidate Brian Schottenheimer being hired, two of their former assistants have found the grass much greener on the other side. As if the Cowboys going 7-10 and missing the playoffs entirely after winning the division a year ago didn’t offer enough potential for their front office to finally learn some hard lessons, the cherry on top has to be the two teams finishing ahead of them still vying for the Lombardi trophy. Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images The Cowboys are well aware that a rapidly growing number of younger fans are coming to know them more for their playoff failures since 1996 and not anything close to their own history of hoisting the game’s ultimate prize. The actual nuts and bolts, football-related reasons why the Cowboys have fallen off so much feel as far away as their Super Bowl XXX win, and unfortunately adding the Commanders and Eagles reaching this point with their former coaches hasn’t seemed to help much. The Cowboys went a combined 1-3 against these teams this season, with a wacky, impossible to replicate fourth quarter win at the Commanders in Week 12. Aside from that the reasons these teams are better than the Cowboys on the field are obvious, and have been on display for the Eagles in playoff wins against the Packers and Rams so far, and likewise for the Commanders against the Buccaneers and top-seeded Lions on the road. One of the results of being faced with an early start to the offseason in Dallas was supposed to be the jolt needed to actually address the future of the team. Instead the Cowboys appear just as rudderless as they were throughout a meaningless regular season they brought upon themselves. So, with less than 48 hours until either Kellen Moore or Dan Quinn is actually handed a trophy, let’s take a closer look at the reality the Cowboys currently find themselves in. The Coaching Factor Robert Saleh. Leslie Frazier. Kellen Moore. Brian Schottenheimer. Those are the four names of the only coaches to officially interview for the Cowboys head coaching vacancy. This is the list produced by Jerry Jones’ reported “solo mission” to find his franchise’s next coach after five seasons of Mike McCarthy. No Ben Johnson, who went to the Chicago Bears. No Aaron Glenn, who is now the head coach of the New York Jets. No Mike Vrabel, who predictably returned to the New England Patriots. Even the slight intrigue of the Cowboys starting the interview process with Saleh and then adding Frazier, signaling a potential shift to a defensive mind after a decade and a half of Garrett and McCarthy specializing in offense, was quickly swept up in the momentum of another offensive hire feeling inevitable once Schottenheimer became the first candidate to reach a second interview. The very fact the Cowboys needed a new head coach after rumors and speculation they wanted McCarthy back, and it was more of the former coach’s decision to part ways than it was the front office was surprising. McCarthy has since interviewed for the now-taken Bears job as well as the still-open Saints job. If this is true, hiring Schottenheimer is the closest thing to McCarthy, his offensive coordinator for the last two seasons, and is probably also the closest thing the Cowboys can do to tell the fans they don’t see a need for real change. Schottenheimer has never had an opportunity to call plays for the Cowboys, but the bad taste left in the mouth of how the offense looked so inept and fundamentally broken under both McCarthy and Schottenheimer’s guidance in 2024 is enough to feel like retaining any significant part of the previous staff on this side of the ball is a bad idea. There is another layer to this that perhaps gets even darker. Again, if it remains true that the Cowboys were sent into scramble mode even just a little bit by McCarthy’s exit, their final interview list paints a picture of not having the easiest time in the world convincing coaches to consider the job. When the quarterback responsible for three of the five Super Bowls in the team’s history calls the job “not exactly coveted”, there is fire where this smoke blows. The Cowboys clearly had their opportunity to choose Quinn as their head coach if they wanted to over the three seasons he was McCarthy’s defensive coordinator, sticking with McCarthy and watching Quinn remain loyal. This loyalty ran out at the exact same time the magic of Quinn’s defense did as well, as a 48-32 beatdown at the hands of the Packers in the Wild Card round last year hurt Quinn’s prospects as a head coach candidate elsewhere. It took a while, but
Report: It was believed Kellen Moore coveted Dallas Cowboys job
Stephen Lew-Imagn Images Kellen Moore reportedly coveted the Cowboys job that went to Brian Schottenheimer. After about two weeks the Dallas Cowboys finally made a move at head coach on Friday night and chose to hire Brian Schottenheimer, their offensive coordinator over the last two seasons. Schottenheimer was also on staff for one year prior to that. To say that the Schottenheimer thing came out of nowhere for the Cowboys would be to put the situation quite mildly. It all began on Monday morning when he appeared as the betting favorite by one oddsmaker and by that day’s end he had been scheduled to interview formally with the team. Yes, he was the betting favorite before an interview even happened. As the week wore on Schottenheimer would gain a second interview, the only candidate to do so, and on Friday night at just about 10pm ET the news was made official. Schottenheimer was indeed the only candidate to formally interview twice, but three others did so once apiece: Kellen Moore, Robert Saleh and Leslie Frazier. This time last week it really felt like Moore might be the top choice by Cowboys brass, but obviously opinions changed. Whether opinions were impacted by Moore’s current team in the Philadelphia Eagles still being active in the playoffs and him therefore unavailable for activities that have to get underway or any other reason, there was seemingly a pivot. In the aftermath of the Schottenheimer news becoming official, there were many pieces of information reported by various insiders. Among the thoughts that ESPN’s Todd Archer offered was that Moore reportedly coveted this job. Coaches, executives and industry people I spoke to were shocked that Schottenheimer rose to the top of Jerry Jones’ list above seemingly more qualified candidates. Eagles offensive coordinator Kellen Moore, a former Cowboys player and the former OC in Dallas, was believed to covet the job and there is surprise in league circles that Dallas didn’t wait to explore that possibility more fully. There are two ways to read the report from Archer here. The first is obvious in that an assumption can be made he is saying that Moore coveted the job this cycle and wanted the job and is therefore upset that he did not get it. There is certainly logic to that idea. Another perspective though is that the belief that Moore coveted the job could have been one held by many prior to the process unfolding. Maybe everybody in question believed that Moore long coveted the job, but that he individually ultimately felt differently. There are a number of possible realities here. That the Cowboys job is or was a coveted job at any point this cycle by Kellen Moore or anyone else is an idea that another former quarterback of the team would seemingly disagree with. You will recall that on the day that Dallas and Mike McCarthy officially parted ways that Troy Aikman blasted the team’s process and specifically said that he did not believe the job to be a coveted one. He used that exact word. Troy Aikman on the Dallas Cowboys: “I thought Mike McCarthy would be the head coach, so this is a bit of a surprise for me today… It suggests that there’s not a real plan… To say that it’s a coveted job, I’m not sure I would necessarily agree with that.” ️#NFL pic.twitter.com/M6cmb1dOaO — Awful Announcing (@awfulannouncing) January 13, 2025 Maybe Moore really wanted the job and is bummed out that he did not get. Perhaps Moore thought he wanted the job and things ultimately changed for him or the team. Whatever the case the job officially belongs to Brian Schottenheimer, whether it was coveted or not at any point in recent history.
Twitter, Bluesky reactions to Jones’ flawed process that made Schottenheimer the Cowboys HC
Late into the night, the Dallas Cowboys made an announcement of their new head coaching hire. Offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer has now taken over the reins, after being on Mike McCarthy’s staff over the last three years. Fans and media have watched a weird coaching search play out since the end of the regular season. Dallas had a one-week, exclusive negotiating window with McCarthy, allowing them to deny the Chicago Bears permission to interview him despite his contract’s expiration. It’s been said one of the reasons McCarthy walked was because Owner Jerry Jones insisted Jason Witten be part of the next coaching staff. Jones reportedly didn’t have any foresight that McCarthy would turn down his offers and walk away, and was left holding the bag, scrambling to execute a last-minute coaching search. He missed his window to interview two well-regarded coordinators, the Lions Ben Johnson and Aaron Glenn, during the wild-card round, as both took jobs before ever talking with Dallas. There was a conversation, but no interview, with Colorado head coach Deion Sanders, and former NFL coaches Leslie Frazier and Robert Saleh were brought in for interviews that satisfied the NFL’s Rooney Rule. The club had a virtual interview with former assistant and current Philadelphia OC Kellen Moore, but for the past week, it’s been clear to those in the know that the team was focusing on Schottenheimer. Frustrated with the process, fans locked in on the Jones’ obvious preference for hiring people they are already familiar with, afraid to go outside the organization for a head coach unless they had proven successful elsewhere. This clear hole in their process is seen as emblematic of the reasons it’s been three decades since the club has seen true success, unable to escape the divisional round of the playoffs, often succumbing in the wild-card round. And for that reason, Schottenheimer is a frustrating choice for many. Failure shouldn’t be expected; the things that make a HC successful aren’t necessarily tied into being a savant as OC or DC. The animosity is more about the fact the process in Dallas is ridiculously flawed and everyone seems to know it except for the billionaires making the decisions. As such, social media reactions have ranged from despair, apathy, laughter and everywhere in between. Here are some of the best responses. BlueSky Cowboys fans this morning.. [image or embed] — KD Drummond (@kddrummondnfl.bsky.social) January 25, 2025 at 10:00 AM No matter how bad things may seem for the Lions with coaches leaving things could be worse. We could be the Dallas Cowboys. Imagine though showing this tweet to fans of both teams in the 1990s. #Lions | #OnePride [image or embed] — The Majors Detroit (@tmsnxdetroit.bsky.social) January 25, 2025 at 8:36 AM Happy first full day of Brian Schottenheimer being the head coach of the Dallas Cowboys to you and yours — RJ Ochoa (@rjochoa.bsky.social) January 25, 2025 at 8:57 AM The Brian Schottenheimer Career Summary graphic is probably a bit unfair but because I feel like Brian Schottenheimer has personally made my life worse I am posting it anyway [image or embed] — Rodger Sherman (@rodger.bsky.social) January 24, 2025 at 10:17 PM Convinced that Jerry will outlive us all and continue to serve as Owner/GM in the form of Krang #NFLSKY #DallasCowboys #Cowboys [image or embed] — LarussoTG (@larussotg.bsky.social) January 25, 2025 at 1:43 AM We were promised Prime Time and we got Home Shopping Club. #dallascowboys — sheridanchambers.bsky.social (@sheridanchambers.bsky.social) January 25, 2025 at 9:27 AM Twitter