Tunnel of Darkness: Nightmarish Cowboys season is about to come to a close
With Super Bowl LIX on the horizon, the nightmarish 2024-25 season for the Dallas Cowboys is about to mercifully come to a close. After three straight 12-win seasons that included two NFC East titles, the Cowboys floundered through an embarrassing campaign.
The mess of a year couldn’t have been a surprise to those paying attention. It began with a disaster of an offseason where the front office decided it was better to wait and sign their best players to extensions until training camp. That mistake was compounded by the team deciding to not participate in free agency while allowing many of their own free agents to walk out the door.
It was a disappointing offseason that was made worse by Jerry Jones’ “all-in” comments. Savvy fans knew better than to believe the Cowboys were going to spend money and be aggressive in acquiring talent since it would’ve signaled a major change in organizational philosophy, but it was something that followed the team around for months leading up to the regular season.
When September arrived, things appeared to turn. The team extended quarterback Dak Prescott on opening day and blew out the Cleveland Browns in Week 1. The Cowboys’ performance provided hope that the previous six months of worrying were all for nothing.
Reality smacked the Cowboys in the face in Week 2, and the disaster many predicted was beginning. There were numerous blowouts throughout the year as the team finished 7-10 and in third place in the division. Dallas finished a putrid 2-7 at home, which included an embarrassing incident with the sun shining through the large windows and AT&T Stadium contributing to a losing storyline against the Philadelphia Eagles. The episode was made worse by Jones remaining defiant that the franchise wouldn’t draw the curtains for Cowboys games like the stadium does for other events.
The Cowboys weren’t just getting humiliated, they were finding new ways to lose. Their special teams unit blocked a punt late in the game against the Cincinnati Bengals, which turned disastrous when cornerback Amani Oruwariye tried to recover and run with it. Instead of a game-winning play for Dallas, Oruwariye fumbled the ball away and the Bengals recovered it, which led to the winning score just three plays later.
Injuries were also a theme for the Cowboys, who had many of their best players miss chunks of the season, including Prescott, defensive end DeMarcus Lawrence, and CB DaRon Bland.
As if the team’s record wasn’t bad enough, it was a season that saw the Eagles soar back to the top of the division fueled by free agency pickup of the year, running back Saquon Barkley. Barkley, who came from another division rival, ran for over 2,000 yards. To make things worse, the Washington Commanders saw a resurgence under rookie quarterback Jayden Daniels, who looks like he’s going to be a problem for the Cowboys’ defense for years to come.
The Eagles and Commanders both finishing ahead of the Cowboys and making the postseason further stuck the knife into the craw of Jones’ organization. It also had to hurt that the top two coordinators during McCarthy era in Dallas both played big roles in the Eagles and Commanders’ success. Kellen Moore and Dan Quinn left the Cowboys and found prosperity with NFC East rivals.
The 2024-2025 season still might not have felt so bad if the postseason hadn’t been a kick in the teeth for the Cowboys as well. The team didn’t make the playoffs, but that didn’t stop the embarrassment. The Commanders beat the Tampa Bay Buccaneers to advance to the divisional round where they pulled off a major upset of the Detroit Lions, making it to their first NFC Championship game in 33 years. That left the Cowboys with the longest title game drought in the NFC.
It didn’t make things better that the Commanders’ win over the Lions meant they’d matchup with the Eagles, who got a home game as the No. 2 seed, for the right to go to the Super Bowl. When Philadelphia won that game, it marked the third Super Bowl appearance for the Eagles in the last eight years, a feat that crushes every Cowboys fan who counts the Eagles as their biggest rival.
This hasn’t been a fun season for the Cowboys, and it could hit a peak level of frustration if the Eagles win Super Bowl LIX. Hopefully that doesn’t happen, there have been too many dreams coming true for the Cowboys rivals in 2024-2025, while they have been living in a nighmare. Thankfully, the NFL season is about to end and the reset can begin.
A shot at better season in 2025 is just around the corner.
Read all the best Cowboys coverage at the Austin American-Statesman and Cowboys Wire.