It’s not often a critical December loss brought on by a botched special teams play in the waning moments of a game is only the second most terrible thing to happen to the Cowboys, but in the wake of DeMarvion Overshown’s season ending knee injury, that’s exactly what it is.

The 5-8 Cowboys losing another game, in any fashion, is old hat in Dallas this year. 2024 has been a season to forget and even a recent two-game winning streak couldn’t vault the Cowboys into contender status. Losing one of the youngest and most exciting players to a significant knee injury is unquestionably the headline following Week 14.

After missing all of the 2023 season to an ACL on his other knee, Overshown made it 13 games before a second, even more significant injury did the same in Year 2. The Cowboys were just starting to understand what Overshown could do as an NFL player. The 6-foot-2, 220-pound heatseeking missile established himself as the Cowboys second best pass-rusher, top run stopper and promising coverage man.

Overshown was a man without a position in all the right ways. Reminiscent of Micah Parsons, Overshown served as the Cowboys not-so-secret weapon whose only limitation is the creativity of the coaching staff designing plays for him. With Dak Prescott and Zack Martin already sidelined for the year, the loss of Overshown serves as salt in an already festering wound in Dallas.

Unfortunately, the bad news doesn’t end there. Tears to Overshown’s ACL, MCL, and PCL are said to threaten his entire 2025 season as well. The timing and severity of the injury isn’t something that a simple offseason can cure, and the Cowboys have to operate like their youngest and brightest star may not be back until 2026.

The impact of this from a roster-building perspective is rather significant. As stated earlier, Overshown is a special player who serves multiple roles. The Cowboys can’t expect to fill those roles with just one player but likely need to target two or more in the draft.

Linebacker, the position Overshown is technically listed at, is the obvious draft need for Dallas. Overshown was Dallas’ top LB this season and with Eric Kendricks likely to leave in the offseason, the Cowboys need to add new LBs in a big way this coming draft cycle. Even with the expected ascension of rookie Marist Liufau, the Cowboys need to find at least two high quality replacements through free agency and the draft.

Overshown the pass rusher also needs to be replaced. He was Dallas’ second-best pass rusher this season and was on track to be No. 2 again in 2025 before the injury. Overshown was a pass rusher who could blitz from anywhere and could be moved constantly to exploit mismatches. It’s not something a traditional defensive end can do and it’s not something a normal LB can do either. It’s a role that’s not easily filled and frankly, may never get filled.

With Overshown gone the Cowboys need to find a player with high end speed and sideline-to-sideline range, they need a moveable pass rusher, and they need a fearless run stopper. Best guess is it will take two draft picks just to partially cover the loss of Overshown this spring. With so many needs already on the docket for the 2025 NFL draft, this is terrible news for a team hoping to bounce back next year.

Related articles

[affiliatewidget_smgtolocal]